The End of Meta’s Fact-Checking: What It Means for the Internet and Brand Marketers

Mark Zuckerberg’s announcement that Meta will eliminate third-party fact-checking on Facebook, Instagram, and Threads signals a seismic shift in the way misinformation could spread online. The pivot to a Community Notes system—similar to what X (formerly Twitter) implementedunder Elon Musk—is a gamble that could fundamentally reshape the internet’s information ecosystem, and it holds profound implications for social media platforms, users, and brand marketers alike.

In a video statement, Zuckerberg framed this move as a way to restore free expression across Meta’s platforms. The company will phase out its independent fact-checking partnerships in favor of a crowdsourced model where users themselves will flag and add context to misleading posts. This shift is part of a broader rollback of Meta’s content moderation policies, including lifting restrictions on politically charged topics like immigration and gender identity. Joel Kaplan, Meta’s Chief Global Affairs Officer, explained that these changes aim to reduce the over-enforcement of policies that have frustrated users and mistakenly censored legitimate speech.

Critics argue this will allow more harmful content on the platform. Given Meta’s platforms’ reach of over 3 billion daily active users, the stakes are incredibly high. The decision to shift moderation responsibilities to its users echoes similar changes made by Musk at X, which resulted in a chaotic online environment rife with hate speech and misinformation.

Though framed as a return to “free expression,” the consequences of loosening content moderation could usher in a new era of mass misinformation. Meta’s previous reliance on third-party fact-checkers was far from perfect, but a study from MIT Sloan of over 14,000 participants shows that fact-checking labels, even when users distrust the fact-checkers, did reduce its spread. Meta’s shift to community-based fact-checking also raises significant concerns about the speed, accuracy, and effectiveness of such a system. A study from the University of Luxembourg and the University of Melbourne found that X’s Community Notes feature was often too slow to counter misinformation during the most viral stage of its spread. Given that Meta’s platforms have over 3 billion daily active users, the potential for harmful content to go unchecked is far greater than what we’ve seen on X.

Brand marketers should expect social platforms to potentially become more chaotic and less predictable. Advertisers have long relied on social media platforms to offer brand-safe spaces, but Meta’s new policy could jeopardize that.

We’ve already seen the impact of reduced content moderation on X, where ad revenue dropped by 60% following Musk’s overhaul. While Meta’s sheer scale and reach may prevent an exodus of advertisers, the risks to brand reputation remain high.

To prepare for this shift, brand marketers must rethink their social media strategies with a clear focus on building trust—the most important currency in this evolving digital landscape. Here’s how they can adapt:

1. Invest in social programs that build 1-to-1 trust with stakeholders:Brands need to prioritize direct engagement with their audiences through personalized interactions that foster trust and loyalty. This can include community-building initiatives, corporate social responsibility programs, and partnerships with trusted organizations.
2. Double down on community management: In an era of misinformation, community management teams must be more active than ever. Engaging directly with social audiences helps brands clarify their stance, address concerns in real-time, and reinforce their values.
3. Invest heavily in social listening and monitoring:As Meta’s Community Notes system opens up more opportunities for disinformation to spread, brands need robust social listening tools to detect and address harmful narratives early. Continuous monitoring ensures that brands can respond quickly to potential reputational threats.
4. Stick to your values, even in the face of uncertainty:Consistency in brand values is critical during times of chaos. Brands that maintain their core principles and communicate them authentically will be better positioned to earn and retain their audience’s trust.

Meta’s decision to end fact-checking and embrace a hands-off moderation approach signals a broader cultural shift in how social platforms balance free expression with responsible governance. For brand marketers, this is both a challenge and an opportunity. Those who adapt to these changes by focusing on transparency, reliability, and humanity in their messaging will be best positioned to navigate the turbulent waters ahead.

Join the conversation here or get in touch with us below: